Huffington Post UK posted a great piece about Stephen Fry (who played Mycroft clothed and unclothed in A Game of Shadows (2011)) and his remarks on the 125th anniversary of Sherlock Holmes “So raise a glass to the greatness of Doyle and the eternal glory of Sherlock Holmes, ushered into this world 125 years ago” as well as Portsmouth’s Lancelyn Green Collection displaying a beautiful first edition copy of A Study in Scarlet. “Due to its fragile condition, A Study in Scarlet is not on permanent display but will feature in the exhibition along with other items from the collection as well as activities based on Holmes’ first outing.” The RLG Collection has approximately 55,000 items. For more information about Mr Richard Lancelyn Green (1953 - 2004) and his bequeathed collection to the Portsmouth Library, read a short yet succinct profile of him here and a description of the collection here. Short pieces about the exhibition were published by BBC News as well as the London Evening Standard. For a comprehensive, exhaustive and fascinating annotated checklist and census of all known copies of the first edition of STUD, check out Best of Sherlock’s extremely helpful ‘Beeton’s Christmas Annual 1887’. Finally, watch this short Stephen Fry video discussing ACD, Sherlock Holmes, Richard Lancelyn Green and the venerable Portsmouth collection.

[Cover for Beeton’s Christmas Annual 1887 which featured the very first appearance of ACD’s Sherlock Holmes in A Study on Scarlet.]
MX Publishing announced that Dan Andriacco’s (author of Baker Street Beat and The 1895 Murder) short story “Sherlock Holmes: The Peculiar Persecution of John Vincent Harden” has been translated into Persian, which is of course the native tongue of the poet Hafez referenced by Holmes in “The Case of Identity” (ie. Sherlock Holmes: “If I tell her she will not believe me. You may remember the old Persian saying, “There is danger for him who taketh the tiger cub, and danger also for whoso snatches a delusion from a woman.” There is as much sense in Hafiz as in Horace, and as much knowledge of the world.”). John Vincent Harden is of course “the well known tobacco millionaire” referenced by Holmes in “The Adventure of the Solitary Cyclist” as one of the important cases he was working on in April of 1895. It must be an excellent feeling to see your name adorning a published book but even more exciting to see the cover of a book you’ve published yet in language whose script you can’t even read let alone the language. Congratulations to Mr Andriacco for being published in both the West and the East!

[Translated cover of the pastiche ”Sherlock Holmes: The Peculiar Persecution of John Vincent Harden” by Dan Andriacco on MX.]
FreemanWeb posted the text of an extremely long and interesting interview with Martin Freeman from the Sunday Times Magazine discussing Peter Jackson’s upcoming The Hobbit film (the Sunday Times is behind a pay-wall but FreemanWeb has pasted the text on their blog). As most of you know, Mr Freeman was cast in the lead role of Bilbo Baggins (of the Shire) based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s novel The Hobbit, or There and Back Again. Apparently, according to The Sun, “Freeman almost lost the lead role in the new movie The Hobbit because he was contracted to play Dr Watson for the BBC.” No word whether Benedict Cumberbatch almost lost his chance to play fire breathing dragon Smaug because of his BBC Sherlock obligations. From the Sunday Times interview: Freeman on looming mega-fame: “he’s found an even wider audience playing Watson, the morally centered sidekick to Benedict Cumberbatch’s eccentrically brilliant Holmes in the BBC’s Sherlock. He’s aware that his next film is about to jettison him into previously uncharted territory: global stardom. It’s not something he’s particularly comfortable about. “You have to police yourself not to become an idiot about it. Because it’s not normal and it doesn’t happen to people with normal jobs,” he says, having clearly agonized over the subject before. “If you’re a doctor — and what’s more important than that? — they don’t stop you in the street and say ‘loved the way you took that pulse!’ So it’s skewed and it’s silly. I know that. But I think I’ve been pretty rigorous and self-flagellating about it.” Good ol’ Freeman, a fixed point in a changing age.

[Dr Watson stabbing the corpse of Jim Moriarty on the roof of St Barts in a BBC Sherlock deleted scene.]
Sherlock Peoria in this week’s valiant attempt at defending the honor of the Canon against the debasing forces of Elementary suggests a thought experiment, originally devised by Ellery Queen in Challenge to the Reader (1938), where “within a single volume, gathered twenty-five of the greatest fictional detectives of the day, from Sherlock Holmes to Sam Spade, from Father Brown to Craig Kennedy. And then Ellery Queen changed the names of all of the detectives in all of the stories. The challenge to the reader was to figure out which story featured which detective.” Mr Brad Keefauver suggests that when this challenge is taken up by either Guy Ritchie’s Sherlock Holmes or Moffat’s BBC Sherlock, the reader will have no difficulty “recognizing the result as Sherlock Holmes” - but of course when applied to CBS’s Elementary “suddenly you’re in with a host of other CBS procedural shows [such as] The Mentalist, not to mention Monk, House M.D., Psych, Perception, Person of Interest, C.S.I. and all those other Sherlock-ish shows that came before.” As much as I’ve personally enjoyed Mr Keefauver’s myriad earlier attempts at condemning Elementary (eg. his Aquaman comparison is rather astute), I think he’s completely and compellingly hit the nail on the head with everything that’s wrong with the show. But before you swear a blood oath to assassinate Keefauver and/or permanently unsubscribe Always1895.net from your RSS feeds (please abstain from at least doing the latter), remember he’s not (necessarily) saying Sherlockians should never watch Elementary or that one can’t be entertained by Elementary; he’s attempting to show via a creative and effective intuition pump (philosopher Daniel Dennett’s term for thought experiment) that Elementary doesn’t have very much to do with Sherlock Holmes, with the further implication that equating Elementary with real Sherlock Holmes ‘stuff’ could be potentially detrimental to the Sherlockian legacy (roughly speaking). Note: If you’re interested in reading Challenge to the Reader, you can ‘borrow’ it form Open Library (just signup for a free account and learn about eBook borrowing here).

[Cover of Challenge to the Reader (1938) edited by Ellery Queen.]
The Wolfe Pack - what scions are to Sherlockian culture, the Wolfe Pack is to Nero Wolfe and Rex Stout aficionados - is hosting their annual Black Orchid Weekend (Nov 30 - Dec 2). Similar to BSI Weekend, there are dinners, lectures, meetings, etc. I’ve recently began reading Rex Stout’s Nero Wolfe books (33 novels, 39 short stories) systematically so maybe next year I’ll be prepared to check out the doings of the wonderfully named Wolfe Pack. Rex Stout, aside from being a mystery novelist of major renown, was an early Sherlockian and BSI member who is perhaps most famous/infamous in the Sherlockian world for his “Watson Was a Woman” talk at a BSI dinner in 1941 (“his tongue-in-cheek humour did not fare well in that venue”) and later that year published in The Saturday Review of Literature, Vol 23, No. 19 (the March 1, 1941 issue). Mr Stout also reviewed Vincent Starrett’s classic work of Sherlockian scholarship The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes in an essay, oft reprinted, “Genesis of a Detective”. Note: Expect to read considerably more about Rex Stout in the coming months as I delve deeper into his Nero Wolfe novels as well as I re-read various bits of information I have on him, mainly from Jon Lellenberg’s BSI Archival History series (the red, muliti-volume history of the BSI).

[Rex Stout with a few fellow BSI Sherlockians you definitely should recognize. Photograph and information from page about Rex Stout and his Sherlockian/BSI connection on NeroWolfe.org.]
Quick Sherlock Links:
Baker Street Babes posted audio and video from a Q&A moderated by Baker Street Babes Curly, Kafers, Maria, & Ardy with BBC Sherlock composer Michael Price and blog writer Joe Lidsterand (and by “blog writer” they mean the guy that writes the ‘in-show’ blogs for Sherlock Holmes: the Science of Deduction, John Watson MD, Molly Hooper and of course Connie Prince) from their recent and, by all accounts, wildly successful event Sherlopalooza. I just finished listening to this and it’s really interesting; Mr Price and Mr Lidsterand contribute a novel and refreshing take on BBC Sherlock from the perspective of ‘the guy who writes the music for the show’ and ‘the guy who maintains actual blogs of fictional characters’, respectively. One suggestion: if I was in the audience I would have asked whose totally brilliant and awesome idea it was to have John Watsons blog’s hit counter to ‘always’ be stuck on that magical number “1895” - a terrific example of the show’s creators/producers/writer’s explicit respect for the canon and Sherlockian history, specifically Vincent Starrett and his famous 221B Sonnet as well his pioneering work of Sherlockian studies The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes. On a related Baker Street Babes note, check out this picture of Curly’s laptop - what excellent taste in stickers!

[The guy that designed the above banner was one-half of the Sherlopalooza Q&A Joe Lidsterand.]
Laurie R King announced - via @Mary_Russell on Twitter - on her blog Mutterings that she, along with Holmes/Sandman/Lovecraft/Dracula annotator Leslie S Klinger, will releases a new collection of Holmes stories/pastiches titled In the Company of Sherlock Holmes due out in the Fall of 2013. Contributors include: “Sara Paretsky, Michael Connelly, Jeffery Deaver, Meagan Abbott, Denise Hamilton, Lisa Lutz, Denise Mina, Val McDermid, Andrew Grant; and from outside the mystery world: Cornelia Funke, Lev Grossman, Larry Niven, Michael Dirda, Michael Sims, Gahan Wilson, John Reppion & Leah Moore, Michael Scott and Diamond Dagger.” Having previously collaborated on the excellent A Study in Sherlock, Mr Klinger was recently featured on I Hear of Sherlock Everywhere talking about his annotation of Dracula and Ms King just released her 12th Mary Russell novel Garment of Shadows.
Digital Spy posted a “celebration of the men who came before [Jonny Lee] Miller - the five greatest actors to bring Conan Doyle’s detective to life on the small screen…” A fairly predictable list except for #4 Tom Baker (of Fourth Doctor fame) in The Hound of the Baskervilles (1982) - a Holmes TV version you don’t see ‘favorited’ that often.
Londonist features a photo set of a phone box outside of St Barts in Smithfield which serves as an ad hoc shrine to Sherlock Holmes and his ‘fall’ off of the roof of said building.
Markings titled this week’s piece ‘Sherlock’s Motto in “The Creeping Man”’ though Mr Ray Wilcockson could have just as easily called it ‘Makings glorious connections between disparate elements of the Canon, the life of ACD and Sherlockiana not to mention the Great Seal of Utah and the motto of New York State, et cetera’. An entertaining romp through the uncharted territory of a mind dedicated to the Great Detective.
Aeon published an essay by Sherlockian psychologist Maria Konnikova titled: ‘The Empathy Machine: Sherlock Was Right – New Research Shows That Seeing Through Another’s Eyes Takes a Detached Mind Not Just a Warm Heart’. Enlightening reading to be sure, of interest to the Sherlockian and literary fan with a penchant for the cognitive sciences alike. You can also listen to an audio version of ‘The Empathy Machine’ via SoundCloud. Ms Konnikova has a book due out in January 2013 on Viking entitled Mastermind: How To Think Like Sherlock Holmes and there’s no doubt every Sherlockian will want to absorb Ms Konnikova’s unique and scientifically rigorous Sherlockian perspective. Sherlockology recently posted a review: “Moving through principles of logic and deduction, creativity and imagination, Mastermind puts 21st century neuroscience and psychology in service of understanding Holmes’ methods.”
[Maria Konnikova’s new book Mastermind is set to be released in January 2013.]
Gods of Gotham is a video walking tour led by Lyndsay Faye, author of the tremendous historical fiction novel of the same name set in New York in the 1840s about the first official NYC police force. Even if you have yet to read Gods of Gotham (though you must!), this virtual tour of lower Manhattan is fascinating.
Rosenlaui scanned this very cool Vasily Livanov (from the Russian Sherlock) autographed photograph from the essential though ridiculously oversized The Pictorial History of Sherlock Holmes (1991) by Michael Pointer.

[Vasily Livanov (1935 - present) is currently 77 years old, in Anno Domini Two-Thousand and Twelve.]
Joe Riggs reviews the intriguingly titled Holmes and Watson End Peace by David Ruffle on MX: “This book is well worth its weight in gold. It is fun, mysterious, emotionally captivating, full of twists and did I mention it’s 100% dialogue!” Another add for the ‘to read’ pile recommended by a Sherlockian that knows his business and his books.
Barefoot on Baker Street appears to be changing her mind about whether or not Elementary is rubbish, though Ms Charlotte Anne Walters - much to the disappointment of Sherlock Peoria (cf. above) - appears to be taking a significantly more positive view of the CBS procedural show. In the interest of kind of fair and sort of balanced blog-reporting, peruse “Is It Third Time Lucky For Elementary?” and find out exactly why Ms Walters is having a change of heart. If I was going to have a change of heart, it would be because of fan-art like this: really sad Jonny Lee Miller.(click on image below for a much larger, much sadder version):

[Fan-art of either Sherlock Peoria’s Brad Keefauver after watching the latest Elementary or Jonny Lee Miller as “Mr Elementary” waiting for his prostitute to show up.]
Alistair Duncan posted a fantastic shot of The Strand magazine from the issue which contains the obituary of it’s most famous (and lucrative) author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Also, Mr Duncan recently weighed in on Elementary: “My only observation to date seems to be that people either seem to think the show is awful (because they simply don’t like it or they don’t believe it should be allowed to exist alongside Sherlock) or they think it is an okay show in itself but not really canonical.”
The Stormy Petrels posted “Fandom ‘Friday’ #20- November 17th, 2012” with links to comics, Pinterest fan art, various conceptions of the layout of 221B, ‘ghostbees’ (?) and a leaf from “The Final Problem” (click image below for full-sized version).

[A page from the manuscript of “The Final Problem” currently in the collection of the University of Indiana’s Lilly Library.]
The Game’s Afoot, blog of Molly Carr - author of The Sign of Fear on MX - posts Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s letter to the War Office, 1914: “I have been told that there may be some difficulty in finding offficers for the New Army. I think I may say that my name is well-known to the younger men of this country and that if I were to take a commission at my age it might be of help….” Click to read on.
The Wrap announced that “Paramount is in talks with “The Lion King 1 1/2” writer Evan Spiliotopoulos to write the script for the remake of Young Sherlock Holmes”. Chris Columbus, who is producing for Paramount “wrote the original Young Sherlock Holmes, which was executive produced by Steven Spielberg and Frank Marshall, and directed by Barry Levinson. Released in 1985, the story centered on Holmes and Watson after they meet at a British boarding school and stumble upon a series of murders.” Den of Geek regurgitates the above news, but with an air of pessimism where as The Movies hits a more optimistic tone. If you are unfamiliar with the movie, check out a trailer for the original Young Sherlock Holmes.
Meiringens posted a still from Granada’s Sherlock Holmes, which actually borrows Holmes’ line about Watson’s particular brand of humour from The Valley of Fear Part 1, Chapter 1: The Warning. Personally, I can never ignore a good reference to Watson and his pawky humor.

[“A touch! A distinct touch!” cried Holmes. “You are developing a certain unexpected vein of pawky humour, Watson, against which I must learn to guard myself.” (VALL)]
Tea at 221B does it again - and I can’t help myself from re-posting every lovely and magnificent Frederic Dorr Steel illustration I come across - with a haunting illustration of a once-and-for-all defeated Colonel Sebastian Moran being lead away in darbies by Lestrade and company following the events of “The Empty House”.
